HealthLife.com
HealthLife.com » Health » Fitness
HEALTH

Trans-fats And Saturated Fats Confused: A Potentially Good Study Makes Dangerous Conclusions

By John Benson
HealthLife.com Contributor
Updated: August 23, 2008
Daniel DeNoon from WebMD Medical News wrote a brief review on a Wake Forest University study dealing with trans fats, or partially-hydrogenated fractal oils that have been linked directly to heart disease due to their mutated biological structure.

From the WebMD article:

"In the study, researchers fed 51 male vervet monkeys a western-style diet - that is, 35% of their diet was fat. Half the monkeys got a lot of trans fat, totaling 8% of their diet. The other monkeys were fed unsaturated fats such as olive oil. Both types of diets were calorie-controlled. In theory, the monkeys should not have gained weight.

"But they did.

"Over six years - what would, in humans, be a 20-year span - the monkeys who ate unsaturated fats upped their body weight by 1.8%.

"Those fed trans fats packed on 7.2%. In humans, that would be enough weight gain to significantly increase risk of diabetes and heart disease."

The Wake Forest study began with a flawed premise, although based on a novel idea. The idea was to see if trans fats alone were sufficient to cause a gain in weight over a long period of time, even when calories were kept exactly the same as compared to a control group. Two groups, both fed the same amount of calories, should not show significant weight gain when compared to each other.
Continue Article Below

The flaw was the use of monkeys, a common mistake researchers make when looking at nutritional paradigms for humans. The digestive system of a monkey is quite different than a human. In fact, our digestive track is much more similar to canines than apes. So, perhaps Rover should have been asked to join the study while Bo-Bo the Chimp took a back seat.

While I believe this study is important - and I also believe that a properly controlled study on canines would reveal a similar conclusion (perhaps not as severe), it's the way the study was written up that should give us all cause for alarm.

There was no distinction between saturated fats and trans-fats.

Now, the argument can be made that the researchers knew the difference - but the American people most certainly do not. WebMD's reach is vast, and such a careless lack of distinction can lead people into believing what the media and medical community have tried to convince us of for years: that saturated fat is the "devil of foods". This is simply not true.

Unlike trans-fats, which are completely useless in human biology, saturated fats are absolutely vital to numerous cellular and hormonal functions. Here is just a partial list. Saturated fats...

  • Raise HDL cholesterol levels, the so-called "good" cholesterol;
  • Are one of the only dietary agents that lower the highly dangerous lipoprotein(a);
  • Do not bind with insulin; something of extreme importance to diabetics;
  • Are critical to hormonal and immune function;
  • Help protect the neuron integrity in the brain, which helps keep memory and cognitive function active as we age;
...and that is a partial list.

Do not be afraid of saturated fats in moderation - or for that matter anything in moderation that is from a whole food source.

Again, the dietary plans in Fit Over 40 are unparalleled when it comes to consuming a nutrition plan that's tasty and healthy, containing ample amounts of natural, unrefined food sources. If you do not have Fit Over 40, grab it today and see for yourself...

...oh, and watch out for those obese monkeys with bags of Oreo Cookies.
Free Profile
Age: Current Weight:
Height: ft in Target Weight:
Sex:
 
Free Profile
Related Fitness Articles
The Evolution of Cardio
Posted on January 05, 2009
5 Common Ab Myths
Posted on December 10, 2008
Sponsor Links